A federal judge in Hawaii ruled on Monday that the Trump administration violated the Endangered Species Act when it approved a planned auction of seabed mining leases in the Pacific Ocean off American Samoa, according to a New York Times report published by the Honolulu Star-Advertiser.
Judge Jill Otake of the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii found that the National Marine Fisheries Service "did not even attempt to consider" the potential harm deep-sea mining could cause to endangered marine species before approving the sale.
The ruling voids the agency's approval of a lease sale covering 31 million acres of seabed. It also nullifies the government's finding that the sale was "not likely to adversely affect" protected species, including blue whales and sea turtles.
The sale, described as the first of its kind, had been scheduled for Thursday. It was unclear whether the administration would go ahead with it.
Otake was nominated to the bench by President Donald Trump in 2017.
The lawsuit was brought in August by Earthjustice on behalf of Fa'asao Amerika Samoa, a group that advocates for protecting American Samoan culture and natural resources, and the Conservation Council for Hawaii. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, whose department oversees the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, was among the defendants.
The plaintiffs argued the government's determination was arbitrary and unlawful and that it failed to analyze the effects of mineral exploration, surveying or eventual mining. They said seabed mining requires machinery with the potential "to destroy nearly all life in its path."
Chris Eaton, an Earthjustice attorney, called the decision a "huge victory" and said the sale would be unlawful if it went ahead. "This ruling says that they cannot take that approach," he said of the government's handling of the risks.
Eaton said the government would now need a full consultation under the Endangered Species Act that weighs the effects of mining and other activities after leasing. "That's going to take some time," he said.
The fisheries service declined to comment on Tuesday. Lutnick did not respond to a request for comment, and the Marine Minerals Administration, which organized the sale, did not respond to questions.
Seabed mining is a priority for Trump, who signed an executive order last April instructing NOAA to speed up approvals for mining companies. The practice does not exist in any commercial form, and more than 45 countries have called for a ban or pause.
American Samoa, a U.S. territory in the South Pacific, imposed its own moratorium on mining in 2024, citing significant risks to marine biodiversity. Environmentalists say sediment plumes from mining machinery could devastate deep-sea ecosystems.
A separate Marine Minerals Administration sale of leases off the Northern Mariana Islands, north of Guam, is scheduled for December and faces a similar challenge. Eaton, who also represents plaintiffs in that case, said he expects a similar ruling and that the decision could affect proposed sales off Alaska and Virginia.